Fruita PD Releases Report on Samantha Loy Stop Minutes Before Fatal Crash, Says Officers Did Nothing Wrong

By: Tim Ciesco Email
By: Tim Ciesco Email

The Fruita Police Department released a new report, reviewing how two of its officers behaved when they pulled over 18-year-old Samantha Loy just minutes before she was killed in an alcohol related crash. According to the coroner's report Loy had a BAC of more than twice the legal limit.

The review, which was conducted by the Fruita Police Department, says after going over the reports of the traffic stop, interviewing the officers, and looking at additional information provided by Loy's family, it finds Officer Nick Peck and Officer Josh Dove did nothing wrong that night and they did not violate any policies or procedures.

According to the report, in the early hours of February 8, 2009, Officer Peck was on patrol looking for DUI drivers. Around 1:00am he saw Samantha Loy's car driving what he believed to be faster than the speed limit on Highway 6 & 50. But because he was not equipped with a radar gun to confirm that speed, he began following her. He pulled her over shortly thereafter, saying she failed to use her turn signal twice.

In a follow-up interview with the police department, Officer Peck said although she seemed slightly confused, Loy appeared relaxed and comfortable talking with him. He says "I did not observe any indicators of alcohol or drug impairment from Loy." He also told police he was suffering from a head cold that night and could not breathe well through his nose.

A few minutes after the stop was made, Officer Josh Dove pulled up to the area. The report says while Officer Peck returned Loy's paperwork, Officer Dove looked through the window of the car, keeping an eye out for things like cans, bottles, and pipes. He noted the car was tidy and that he did not see any indicators of alcohol or drugs.

Loy was let go with a verbal warning, which the report says is "acceptable" for the two turn signal violations. The report also states "Verbal warnings are an appropriate method of behavior modification."

In a follw-up interview, Officer Dove details how he made a comment to another officer after returning from the stop that Loy was "very attractive." The review states, however, that because Officer Dove was the backup officer on the stop, the department had determined his comments about Loy's appearance had "no bearing on Officer Peck's decisions."

The report also says that the department is not disputing the fact that Loy was drunk at the time of the stop, or the fact that at the crash site, State Troopers found an empty bottle that smelled like alcohol inside her car. Officials say for the officers to have legally searched the car and find the bottle, they would have had to arrest Loy -- but because they did not believe she was drunk, they could not do that.

The Fruita Police Department says Officer Peck has received extensive training when it comes to DUI's and that he made 11 DUI arrests in 2008.

Police administrative officials familiar with the report were not available for interviews Sunday, as it is the weekend.

Loy's mother recently asked the Fruita City Council to have an outside agency review the officers' stop. She could not be reached for comment Sunday.

You must be logged in to post comments.

Password (case sensitive):
Remember Me:

Read Comments

Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
  • by Sue Location: Grand Junction on Aug 28, 2009 at 07:26 PM
    Peck states in the internal interview that he noticed sam was not wearing a seatbelt when he returned her license to her officer Dove states he noticed she didn't have a seatbelt on because of her low cut dress neather of the officers noticed if she had bothered to put one back on aa she drove away. Seat belts are manditory all over the country except in Fruita. Dove goes back to the statation and talks about her beauty, she is all ready dead. If these officers are allowed to stay on the force then everyone in Fruita is in danger and so are their families. I know my daughter and she had to be way gone to have not but her seatbelt on then she was getting pulled over, and sign for help I think so. I'm appalled at the actions of the Mayor and City Manager of the city of Fruita for them still allowing these officers to be working. Everything they did that night was negligent. Do you know air bags do not deploy if seat beltsd are not on. Let them pull your daughter over even if she is not
KKCO NBC 11 News
2531 Blichmann Avenue
Grand Junction, CO 81505

Station Phone: 970.243.1111
Business Fax: 970.243.1770
Newsroom Fax: 970.245.3793
News Tip & Contest Line: 970.255.8477
Copyright © 2002-2016 - Designed by Gray Digital Media - Powered by Clickability 52843352 -
Gray Television, Inc.