CMU football's Blake Nelson and Asutin Fleer were already named All-Americans by the American Football Coaches Association.
D2Football.com is giving the two seniors the same honor.
Nelson was named a second-team All-American by the website. The defensive end racked up 81 tackles, seven sacks and led the nation with four blocked kicks.
Those numbers led Nelson to earning RMAC Defensive Player of the Year.
Fleer was named to the second team as well.
The offensive linemane was an integral part of the Mavs offensive attack which averaged 257 rushing yards and 450 yards of total offense per game.